Tina was at the Bloomberg Housing Conference last week. Here are her notes:
All,
I attended the Bloomberg conference last week and below are
some notes from the Housing Panel. The panelist were: Sean Donovan Current
Secretary at HUD, Jim Millstein Chairman & CEO of Millstein & Co, LLC
former Restructuring officer, U.S Dept of Treasury and James Lockhart, Vice
Chairman for Wilbur Ross & Co, Federal Housing Finance Agency, Former
Deputy Commissioner and COO social Security Administration
This is according to Sean Donovan (Secretary of HUD):
Housing has reached a bottom. We saw the biggest losses before President Obama
took office and progress has been made. We have seen the best winter of home
sales and we are beginning to see a different view in the markets. He trend is
changing.
There are still 3 barriers to entry: People are being
screened out because of barriers
1-
# of new foreclosures
2-
Shadow inventory
3-
Credit availability- home buyers are being priced out or extra hassles
of getting a loan if even credit worthy, too expensive to obtain credit
-
Upwards of 3-4mm of foreclosures to go on the market with another 2mm in
the pipeline which if this happens will be catastrophic to the housing markets
and we could see 2008 all over again but a lot worse. So on the flip side
of what Sec. Donovan said above about housing getting better this doesn’t bode
well. This would destroy the housing market and neighborhoods with
foreclosures. Crippling our markets yet again. This was not taken well by
groups like us because this just show confidence in our current administration.
-
Affordable housing goals set by the Clinton and Bush administration were
too high
-
The Harp 2.0 refi program set out by the Obama Administration has
worked, there is a need for Congress to move into the private label market with
refi’s
-
there is still uncertainty for about 15-20% of homebuyers
-
Banks are now making mortgages rather selling to Fannie and Freddie
-
The bank’s balance sheets need to shrink by about 20% but they are going
in the wrong direction at this point and there is insufficient capital to
support
-
There are 10.5 Trillion mortgages
Fannie and Freddie- What to do with them and their
future?
The biggest issue with both Fannie and Freddie right now is
there is no general consensus in D.C (congress) as to what to do with them
either unwind or keep solvent.
There is no plan to unwind them or restore solvency. It will
be difficult to get private capital back as they are undercapitalized and until
you bring capital back into both of them this is an ongoing issue. We
need some type of action from Congress. All of the uncertainty is causing a
mass exodus of very talented individuals at these organizations and this will
continue if there is no plan in place or steps being taken from Congress.
There needs to be some consensus as to what to do with the
fate of Fannie and Freddie, if it is decided they will both be kept running
they both need to be recapitalized and better regulated that is a known fact
and something everyone agrees upon. If Congress is going to end both then they
need to just do it and start the process..
Fannie and Freddie hold 55% of the mortgages there needs to
be mechanisms around working these mortgages in the private label market.
There needs to be a fundamental reform in structure to
understand what is being bought in securitization and the focus needs to be
broader than just Fannie and Freddie.
The big barriers to Fannie, Freddie and FHA loans is the
uncertainty around the foreclosure process.
This is why banks are doing less and less origination and
getting out of the origination business
The FHA has raised fees 4x and their market share continues
to drop this reiterates the need for private capital to come back to the
financial system
The big questions is Can private capital come back without
GSE reform? There are currently 6.5T holders of GSE credit so with those
numbers it is too risky for private capital. Until there is some type of gov’t
guarantee in the system the private sector won’t come back at least without any
type of encouragement.
All and all there is a lot of uncertainty right now about
the GSEs and this is going to be an ongoing problem until Congress steps in
with some type of action.
Christina